Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
Did you miss your
activation email?
Home
Download Test
Test Your Download Speed
Test Download AND Upload
Upload Test
Test Your Upload Speed
Test Upload AND Download
Community Forum
Community Forum Home
» Log-In
» Register
Internal Search
Google Powered Search
Computer & Net Guides
ISP Discussion
Forum Sitemap
Member List
Forum Stats
Forum Help and Info
Calendar & Birthdays
Database Stats
Host Stats
Member Stats
Share Score
Misc Tools
Conversion Calc.
Speed Chart
Conversion Table
Create a Test
Share Score
Automatic Test
Forum Archive
RSS and Blog Feeds
Score Database
trace/ping/whois/DNS
Wallpapers
Tweak Guide
!! Forum Search !!
!! Google Search !!
TMN Detailed Sitemap
News
News Home
Join
Theme
See Theme List
America the Beautiful
Blacken
Dark Blood Red
Blue
Blue Black Box
Blue Gray
Brown
Christmas
Dark Blue
ekaf
GL Series (default)
Gray Shades
Original Feel
Green
Greenhouse
Greenhouse Gray
Halloween Theme
Orange
Purple Darkness
Red/pink
Red 'n Black
TurkeyDay!
» Neuron (Default)
Neuron Black
Rise (New!)
Click to read why...
News
:
remember, testmy.net loves you! Show your love back and tell your friends about our great community! We rely 100% on word of mouth advertising, so if you find that the site is useful, tell a friend! ~ Thanks!
November 21, 2009, 10:32:15 AM
testmy.net Broadband
|
Main Forum
|
Make it Faster...
| Topic:
Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
Recommended Tests
TIP:
Test how fast your system is really running
Free Performance Scan
TIP:
Test how many system errors your PC has
Free PC Error Scan
Note: The links above are sponsored links
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
« previous
next »
Topic Tools
Search this topic
Pages
1
Author
Topic: Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not (Read 2983 times)
KBolt
New Member
Offline
Posts: 6
Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
«
on:
November 15, 2008, 09:07:27 PM »
Boosting cable speed on FAST services is NOT possible past certain speeds and setups.
Someone wrote
Quote
The things you need to do if you have Vista and cant reach 90% of advertised speed...
. Well, not quite so...
Someone should also tell that nothing can be done if you have one regular PC connected to cable service >20Mbit/s.
You will NEVER get 90% of the advertised speed, never. No matter what kind of modem or the rest of your rig you have.
If you could plug your PC directly to main fiber you still wouldn't get the full speed.
That is because "PC" can handle fairly small amount of data internally.
In other words : The maximum "speed" of PC:s data handling is lower than the speed of the cable input.
Even if you own fairly hi-end PC (will cost more than pocket money..) you will never get the full (DOWNLOAD) speed.
There is nothing you can do about it ---> No need (no rational reason) to buy >20Mbit/s service.
The full speed of fast cable service is in use when you have 2 or more HIGH QUALITY PC:s, for example, doing downloading.
This is the only way to benefit from services over 20Mbit/s. (And you don't have to tweak...).
P.S. Well assembled PC (made from quality components..) can handle data maybe at the speed of 20..30Mbit/s MAX
(depends greatly what hardware / software is used..).
Logged
RTB
Dead but Alive
Global Moderator
TMN Veteran
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 2152
I'm so evil, I'm hiding half my face from you.
Re: Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
«
Reply #1 on:
November 16, 2008, 04:33:58 PM »
We're not in the 80's anymore though. For throughoutput in a PC the only bottleneck left is the harddisk, which reaches speeds of 50+ MB/s, which is 400Mbit/s or higher. DOCSIS 2.0 cable modems cap around 50 or higher (not sure, but it's far higher than the 20 Mbit you claim), DSL is a distance-dependant connection, but can reach speeds of 24 Mbit (DSL2+) when near the node.
One can and will be able to get the advertised speed through tweaking and finding the right server (close distance and high speed capable), I'm on 24/2.5 and I have seen stable speeds of 2.8 - 2.9 MB/s on certain downloads. On some overloaded networks, picking a moment where the network is least loaded can help too.
One other possible limitation is network speed, most routers operate at 100Mbit, though GBit is available. Budget motherboards offer 100Mbit network connectivity, anything above that is GBit, and expensive ones even have dual GBit. Cat5 cable is not made for GBit, but can reach speeds higher than 100 Mbit. Cat6 should be able to reach 600-700 at least, the exact numbers I do not recall, but once again, far above your 20 Mbit 'cap'.
I will not allow anyone to spread such misinformation on testmy.net.
Logged
<scud> The other day, in the park, I was wondering why frisbees look bigger and bigger as they get closer to you
<scud> And then it hit me
Click me. Or be diminished; one by one.
f
o
l
d
i
n
g
mudmanc4
Ɠξξ₭ òƒ Ɠξξ₭z
Global Moderator
TMN Seasoned Veteran
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 6524
Re: Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
«
Reply #2 on:
November 16, 2008, 04:48:52 PM »
Quote from: RTB on November 16, 2008, 04:33:58 PM
We're not in the 80's anymore though. For throughoutput in a PC the only bottleneck left is the harddisk, which reaches speeds of 50+ MB/s, which is 400Mbit/s or higher. DOCSIS 2.0 cable modems cap around 50 or higher (not sure, but it's far higher than the 20 Mbit you claim), DSL is a distance-dependant connection, but can reach speeds of 24 Mbit (DSL2+) when near the node.
One can and will be able to get the advertised speed through tweaking and finding the right server (close distance and high speed capable), I'm on 24/2.5 and I have seen stable speeds of 2.8 - 2.9 MB/s on certain downloads. On some overloaded networks, picking a moment where the network is least loaded can help too.
One other possible limitation is network speed, most routers operate at 100Mbit, though GBit is available. Budget motherboards offer 100Mbit network connectivity, anything above that is GBit, and expensive ones even have dual GBit. Cat5 cable is not made for GBit, but can reach speeds higher than 100 Mbit. Cat6 should be able to reach 600-700 at least, the exact numbers I do not recall, but once again, far above your 20 Mbit 'cap'.
I will not allow anyone to spread such misinformation on testmy.net.
Damn, how'd I miss this ? I'll second that !
Logged
Don't do what others say - listen to them, but do what you feel good doing. ~ Warren Buffet
Leaps-from-Shadows
New Member
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 5
Re: Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
«
Reply #3 on:
November 17, 2008, 11:18:21 AM »
Sorry, KBolt...
I don't know where you get your information, but it's just plain wrong. Sure, there will always be overhead and most people will never see the full speed of their internet connection because of that, but there is no general 20-30 megabit per second cap.
I have seen download/upload results of 195.42/53.53 megabits per second (200,120 Kbps download, 54,820 Kbps upload) - and that's on university computers, which aren't typically bleeding edge machines.
Logged
KBolt
New Member
Offline
Posts: 6
Re: Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
«
Reply #4 on:
November 21, 2008, 08:19:57 AM »
Quote
there is no general 20-30 megabit per second cap.
I know this, more than well, and I didn't even say that there is some cap. I wrote that there is no point getting superfast connection service only for the exitement of having one and because "they sold it cheap..".
I did exaggerate on some parts for a reason...
Quote
Budget motherboards offer 100Mbit network connectivity
Sure...they offer free games too...( this gategory motherboard are free today if you know where to go and get them..)
Quote
One can and will be able to get the advertised speed through tweaking and finding the right server (close distance and high speed capable), I'm on 24/2.5 and I have seen stable speeds of 2.8 - 2.9 MB/s on certain downloads. On some overloaded networks, picking a moment where the network is least loaded can help too.
So, you are trying to say that it's a kind of a "feature" when client MUST tweak and search (for rest of his/hers life..) to get almost the speed they have bought ? They should stalk the right moment with their tweaked and twisted protocol to get the adverticed speed for just a short moment of download...
Do you really say that it's advisable to use both LANs on dual GBit motherboard for downloading ? Well, be my guest...
I've had dual GBit motherboards for years (like on this Maximus Formula) and other gear that should give the speed it's advertized to give. The true speed of HW is not directly related to the text saying what it's hoped to be. This has been tested during several years on multiple setups and methods.
Quote
I have seen download/upload results of 195.42/53.53 megabits per second (200,120 Kbps download, 54,820 Kbps upload)
I have seen the light....
Really...what kind of network do you have inside the university ? Internet ?
True, on special network setups you can naturally get top speeds. How many average home users do have such connection type to net ? Not many.
I didn't know that this site is only for students that are using direct connections to mainframe...
Quote
I'm on 24/2.5 and I have seen stable speeds of 2.8 - 2.9 MB/s on certain downloads.
In other words, mostly you don't have stable speed.
I'm on 40/2 and I get 21 300Kbit/s +- 2000 (about 2.7 MB/s) down as average. That is as "stable" as it can be but that's INSIDE country. I don't get that if I download from Australia or Siberia.
If you get occassionally 2.8 MB/s (which is over the 24/2.5 theoretical speed..), that's ok, but that is not the speed you can call stable. That's only a random burst speed.
The real misinformation is when someone is trying to convince someone else that it is natural to get 90% of advertized speed on any pile of crapware. No matter of distances etc.
I would call it a fraud.
P.S. If it's somehow limited or forbidden to write negative (the real world..) things here then I'm really sorry. I guess you have to ban me.
«
Last Edit: November 21, 2008, 08:39:11 AM by KBolt
»
Logged
Leaps-from-Shadows
New Member
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 5
Re: Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
«
Reply #5 on:
November 21, 2008, 12:17:11 PM »
Quote
So, you are trying to say that it's a kind of a "feature" when client MUST tweak and search (for rest of his/hers life..) to get almost the speed they have bought ?
The reason tweaking has to be done is that no operating system can accurately guess what kind of internet connection each user has. This means they have to cater to the lowest common denominator, not us high-speed internet users. Anyone who wants more speed than the general 'broadband internet' profile provided by the operating system does need to tweak to get every last bit of performance.
Quote
I have seen the light....
Really...what kind of network do you have inside the university ? Internet ?
True, on special network setups you can naturally get top speeds. How many average home users do have such connection type to net ? Not many.
I didn't know that this site is only for students that are using direct connections to mainframe...
I don't have university internet. I was using somebody else's numbers to illustrate that your supposed hardware cap is in fact nonexistent.
Your claims are alarmist and inaccurate. Please check your facts and refrain from doing the "I did exaggerate on some parts for a reason..." thing on any future posts. Thank you.
Logged
Blako
TMN Friend
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 361
Re: Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
«
Reply #6 on:
November 21, 2008, 01:04:45 PM »
My theory is, the faster your internet the less likly a server can meet your "max" demands. You are correct KBolt, when you say that downloading from obscure servers on the other side of the world don't result in good speeds. Let me see if I can word this properly. If the servers, distance, and network traffic (all things out of your control) were left in a state of "perfection", then your hardware will often put you within 90% of your advertized speed.
Quote from: KBolt
If you get occassionally 2.8 MB/s (which is over the 24/2.5 theoretical speed..) ... That's only a random burst speed
If there are 8 bits in a byte then RTB has a 3 megabyte/sec download and 0.3125 megabyte/sec upload. Reaching 2.8 of 3 mbyte is greater then 90%.
Lets say a really "slow" old hard drive can read/write at 20 mbyte/sec. Thats 160mbit/sec. Even that is plenty for 100Mbps cat5 cable.
Another use of the word stable: While watching a moving on gametrailers.com I am stable at 3.6Mbps download for 20 seconds. Now you might say, "But you have a 10Mbps connection." Thats true. By clicking on the movie statistics you will find it is playing at 3.3Mbps, thus the server is only giving me 300Kbps more then I need to watch the video smoothly. I believe this is to keep demand on their servers low so they can better cater to "the masses."
To conclude:
When the world around you is running smoothly (network wise), the majority of users can reach 90% of advertized speeds. When things out of your control are,
interupted, you might as well be gambling.
http://www.coolnsmart.com/gambling_quotes/
Logged
The fastest path on a race track is one where you turn the least.
Example of a Hyperplane: a three dimensional plane in the fourth dimension.
RoadRunner advertised = (10Mb?/1Mb?)
Cap at = (10.24Mb/1.024Mb)
Highest PowerBoost= (31Mbps for 1 sec)
Worst Sustained = (4000kb/300kb)
Avg. = (8000+kb/900+kb)
Internet caps found at
http://192.168.100.1/diagnostics_page.html
Terayon modem password "icu4at!"
RTB
Dead but Alive
Global Moderator
TMN Veteran
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 2152
I'm so evil, I'm hiding half my face from you.
Re: Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
«
Reply #7 on:
November 21, 2008, 01:23:07 PM »
Quote from: KBolt on November 21, 2008, 08:19:57 AM
I did exaggerate on some parts for a reason...
So you'd be taken even less seriously.
Quote
Sure...they offer free games too...( this gategory motherboard are free today if you know where to go and get them..)
If you still insist on using 486s, or maybe even a Pentium I. P2s, P3s are loose change nowadays.
Quote
So, you are trying to say that it's a kind of a "feature" when client MUST tweak and search (for rest of his/hers life..) to get almost the speed they have bought ? They should stalk the right moment with their tweaked and twisted protocol to get the adverticed speed for just a short moment of download...
Nice exaggeration, it totally nulls anything you try to get across. The TCP protocol itself can even become a bottleneck eventually.
Quote
Do you really say that it's advisable to use both LANs on dual GBit motherboard for downloading ? Well, be my guest...
Where did I say anything on using dual GBit for internet downloads? Besides, harddisks tend to be a bottleneck for single GBit (~125 MB/s), but if you use purely CPU generated traffic, then sure, dual GBit has use.
Quote
I've had dual GBit motherboards for years (like on this Maximus Formula) and other gear that should give the speed it's advertized to give. The true speed of HW is not directly related to the text saying what it's hoped to be. This has been tested during several years on multiple setups and methods.
Prove it. If what someone says goes against the general idea, it is him/her who has to prove he is right, not the people with the general idea.
Quote
True, on special network setups you can naturally get top speeds. How many average home users do have such connection type to net ? Not many.
I didn't know that this site is only for students that are using direct connections to mainframe...
Quit trolling.
Quote
In other words, mostly you don't have stable speed.
I'm on 40/2 and I get 21 300Kbit/s +- 2000 (about 2.7 MB/s) down as average. That is as "stable" as it can be but that's INSIDE country. I don't get that if I download from Australia or Siberia.
If you get occassionally 2.8 MB/s (which is over the 24/2.5 theoretical speed..), that's ok, but that is not the speed you can call stable. That's only a random burst speed.
Of course, the TCP protocol was never made to handle such speeds by default. The fact that I cannot get that speed stable is due to other reasons, such as bittorrent abuse (the weakness of TCP, really).
Quote
The real misinformation is when someone is trying to convince someone else that it is natural to get 90% of advertized speed on any pile of crapware. No matter of distances etc.
I would call it a fraud.
On the other hand, you claim there is no point in technological advance, because of the mythical cap on internet speeds for the general population. If you're allowed to generalize that much, then so can I.
Quote
P.S. If it's somehow limited or forbidden to write negative (the real world..) things here then I'm really sorry. I guess you have to ban me.
Trolls get banned, sure. Don't push your luck.
Blako: The reason that speeds get limited by distance, is that TCP requires interactivity between two nodes. The wikipedia entry on TCP should help you understand.
Logged
<scud> The other day, in the park, I was wondering why frisbees look bigger and bigger as they get closer to you
<scud> And then it hit me
Click me. Or be diminished; one by one.
f
o
l
d
i
n
g
dlewis23
Inactive Moderator
TMN Seasoned Veteran
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 9829
HEY! ill put it down when im good and ready.
Re: Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
«
Reply #8 on:
November 21, 2008, 03:06:44 PM »
Quote from: KBolt on November 15, 2008, 09:07:27 PM
Boosting cable speed on FAST services is NOT possible past certain speeds and setups.
Someone wrote . Well, not quite so...
Someone should also tell that nothing can be done if you have one regular PC connected to cable service >20Mbit/s.
You will NEVER get 90% of the advertised speed, never. No matter what kind of modem or the rest of your rig you have.
If you could plug your PC directly to main fiber you still wouldn't get the full speed.
That is because "PC" can handle fairly small amount of data internally.
In other words : The maximum "speed" of PC:s data handling is lower than the speed of the cable input.
Even if you own fairly hi-end PC (will cost more than pocket money..) you will never get the full (DOWNLOAD) speed.
There is nothing you can do about it ---> No need (no rational reason) to buy >20Mbit/s service.
The full speed of fast cable service is in use when you have 2 or more HIGH QUALITY PC:s, for example, doing downloading.
This is the only way to benefit from services over 20Mbit/s. (And you don't have to tweak...).
P.S. Well assembled PC (made from quality components..) can handle data maybe at the speed of 20..30Mbit/s MAX
(depends greatly what hardware / software is used..).
Ok everything you said is completely wrong.
You can get well over 90% advertised speed. I get over 100% of my advertised speed on my 6 Mbps connection at home. I have a 30 Mbps connection at my office, and we get 32 Mbps, the server I own has a 1 Gbps and can push data out to the internet to another server at 998.4 Mbps, IDK maybe i'm a little F#@&ed up or something but I think that over 90% . Some one correct me if im wrong. lol
You go into a ton of bull S#!t there which is actually funny, I don't see how you could have wrote this when you were sober.
PC's have been capable of handling data over 20 or 30 Mbps for many years. Do you have any idea how fast a modern 7200 RPM hard drive is? Here is a hint, its faster then 20 or 30Mbps.
Logged
Pages
1
testmy.net Broadband
|
Main Forum
|
Make it Faster...
| Topic:
Boosting cable speed on FAST services..not
« previous
next »
Jump to:
Please select a destination:
-----------------------------
Main Forum
-----------------------------
=> General Discussion
=> New Members
=> PC Security
===> Antivirus & Firewalls
===> Spyware & Malware
===> Viruses & Scams
===> Security Threats
=> Show off your scores!
=> Make it Faster...
=> HELP!
===> HELP! With Other Stuff
===> HELP! With Tests
===> HELP! With Forum
===> Programming and Website Help
=====> HTML
=====> PHP
=====> PERL
=====> Server Help
===> Networking and Hardware
===> Overclocking
===> Linux Help
=> News
===> testmy.net News and Updates
===> Off Topic Headline News
=> Online Gaming Discussion
===> Requests
===> America's Army
===> Battlefield
===> Call Of Duty 4
===> Counter-Strike 1.6
===> Counter-Strike : Source
===> Day of Defeat : Source
===> Diablo
===> F.E.A.R
===> Ghost Recon
===> Halo 2
===> Lineage 2
===> Quake
===> Rainbow Six 3
===> World of Warcraft
===> Tribes 2
===> Unreal Tournament
=> Graphics, Sigs and Pictures
===> Test Board
=> Guides
=> Got any ideas to make testmy.net better?
=> Off Topic Discussion
===> Politics & More
-----------------------------
Provider Discussion and Reviews
-----------------------------
=> Add a Provider
=> All Dial-up
=> North American Providers (Including Canada)
===> Canadian Providers
=====> teksavvy.com Canada
=====> xplornet.com Canada
=====> Persona Internet
=====> Rogers Communications
=====> Shaw Communications
=====> Sympatico (Bell Canada)
===> Adelphia Communications
===> ALLTEL Communications
===> AOL
===> AT&T
=====> SBC Global
=====> BellSouth
===> Cable One
===> Cavalier Telephone cavtel.net
===> cebridge.net
===> CenturyTel
===> Charter Communications
===> Clearwire
===> Comcast Cable Communications
===> Country Cablevision
===> Covad communications
===> Cox Communications
===> DMAX Puerto Rico
===> EarthLink
===> EMBARQ
===> Frontier Online
===> HughesNet (DIRECWAY)
=====> DW4000 Information
=====> DW6000 Information
=====> DW7000 Information
===> Insight Broadband
===> Magtel Wireless
===> Mediacom Communications
===> Midcontinent Communications
===> mycingular.net
===> Namesco/NDO (ndo.com)
===> onelinkpr.net Puerto Rico
===> Optimum Online
===> Qwest Communications
===> RCN
===> RoadRunner (Time Warner Cable)
===> seidata.com
===> sigecom.net
===> SkyWay USA
===> Speakeasy
===> Sprint Nextel Corporation
===> Starband
===> Suddenlink
===> SureWest Communications
=====> SureWest Communications FIOS
===> SusCom - Susquehanna Communications
===> TDS - Telephone and Data Systems, Inc
===> Transedge.com
===> Verizon Online
===> Verizon Online FIOS
===> Wave Broadband
===> Wide Open West
===> Wildblue Communications, Inc
=> World Providers (Non-North American)
===> African Providers
===> Asian and Middle Eastern Providers
=====> Asian Providers
=====> Centennial
=====> Digitel
=====> PLDT myDSL
=====> Sify Broadband
=====> Streamyx
=====> Smart Bro (Wi-fi)
===> Australian Providers
=====> Digiplus
=====> Optusnet
=====> Telstra Bigpond
===> UK and European Providers
=====> Bredbandsbolaget
=======> Bredbandsbolaget Fiber
=======> Bredbandsbolaget ADSL, VDSL
=====> Virgin.net (old NTL)
=====> Tiscali
===> Central/South American Providers
-----------------------------
Miscellaneous
-----------------------------
=> Archives
===> Announcements
=> Public Polls
===> Not on index
Print
Advanced search
Loading...
testmy.net's forum is proudly
Powered by SMF
|
SMF © 2006-2007, Simple Machines LLC
© 1999-2009 testmy.net -
Contact
-
Legal
-
Facts & FAQs
Page Loading Stats: This forum Page created in 0.164 seconds with 41 queries.